An argument on whether suicide in the final solution

There are too many people on Earth. The supervisor thought about it for a moment, glanced at me, then departed. Subintentioned Death and Indirect Suicide. The decision to end one's life when terminally ill is frequently construed as rational. Text, Translation, and Interpretation.

Let them rot in their insanity. In this latter case, societies with a higher rate of divorce, for example, should have a higher rate of suicide for those in all marital statuses, and this has been confirmed in the United States.

Unlike direct suicidal behavior, indirect self-destructive behavior is not linked to a specific precipitating stress; hence this behavior is not sudden or impulsive. Durkheim thought that this association was curvilinear, with very high levels of social integration and regulation leading to altruistic and fatalistic suicide, respectively, and very low levels of social integration and regulation leading to egoistic and anomic suicide, respectively.

For nihilistic philosophers, nothing can have a meaning, not even suicide itself. Conclusions It may be that direct intentional acts that result in death i. Durkheim hypothesized that suicide rates were determined by the society's level of social integration that is, the degree to which the people are bound together in social networks and the level of social regulation that is, the degree to which people's desires and emotions are regulated by societal norms and customs.

Suicide is by definition generally considered to be intentioned. Well, the first counter-revolutionary act of every government is to collect the guns, and a necessary element of pre-emptive counter-revolution in the American polity is the disarming of the people.

Medicide Kevorkian listed the rules that he believed should be followed; they include calling for psychiatric consultation, calling for pain specialist consultation, allowing a twenty-four-hour waiting period after final request, conducting extensive patient counseling, and stopping the process if there is any sign that patient is ambivalent.

Battin's criterion of avoidance of harm is essentially the justification that organizations such as the Hemlock Society propose as their fundamental justification of rational suicide.

Repeated inquiries … were not too successful with the exception of his vivid reference to 'thinking about going up on the tower with a deer rifle and start shooting people'. Aaron Beck, a psychiatrist who has developed a system of counseling known as Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy for those suffering from depression and anxiety, and his associates later developed an inventory to measure hopelessness.

Like, you know, gay marriage. Crawley speculates that greater nurturing and caring behavior may similarly reverse many of the stress-related, self-injurious behaviors in humans.


It is acceptable to take a life in self-defense. Most suicidologists choose to try to prevent suicides that come to their attention, assuming that rational suicides, if they exist, are rare, difficult to identify, and merit interventions to challenge their reasoning.

Henry and Short's theory has suggested that an appropriate comparison group for suicides would be murderers, a group that individual theories of suicide have ignored. Mayo presented the definition that a rational suicide must realistically consider alternatives concerning the likelihood of realizing goals of fundamental interest to the person and then choose an alternative which will maximize the realization of those goals.

On the contrary, it may very well be their tragic reaffirmation.

Suicide is NOT the Final Solution

It is not clear that any such interests exists in the case of euthanasia. They cite the cessation of the harm of unbearable suffering as the most common reason for suicide.

Customer reviews

Brief mentions of suicidal behavior can be found throughout his writings, however, and in the psychiatrist Robert Litman attempted to document and synthesize these dispersed thoughts.

Judge Jessica Cooper of Oakland County, Michigan, noted that Kevorkian was not licensed to practice medicine at the time he administered the lethal injection. Shut your relation to the west. Alarms are activated when the system detects suspicious changes in heart rate, breathing rate or body motion that are typically found when an inmate is engaging in a suicide attempt.

And that focus would not be on the weapons used.

Anti-euthanasia arguments

The booking area of any jail is traditionally both chaotic and noisy; an environment where staff feel pressure to process a high number of arrestees in a short period of time.

Reviews by McIntosh, Hubbard, and Lester suggest that more elderly persons may die from indirect suicide than from direct suicidal behavior. The history of arguments and struggles over this principle, throughout the world, is long and clear. It never has and it never will.

Should Suicide be legal

From its corporate militia comrades. Physical diseases are frequently observed, particularly in older suicide pact victims.

Simply stated, correctional staff, as well as medical and mental health personnel, cannot detect, make an assessment, nor prevent a suicide for which they have little, if any, useful training.

It lacked a suicide prevention policy. Thus, for Mill, selling oneself into slavery should be prevented in order to avoid precluding the ability to make further choices. There are many people on the world, but not too many that suicide has to be our final option. Indeed it is because they are powerful and dangerous that they are the nexus of an important political right.

Suicide is a crime in some parts of the world. However, while suicide has been decriminalized in some western countries, the act is still stigmatized and discouraged. In other contexts, suicide could be utilized as an extreme expression of liberty, as is exemplified by its usage as an expression of devout dissent towards perceived tyranny or injustice which occurred occasionally in cultures.

Suicide DeathsDoor - Sep 10, This man shot himself in the head because of debts. My argument for Suicide September 29th, by sunbird.

So,I could blather on here about my depression (2+ yrs) my empty,pathethic,useless life,and listen to people patronizing me and feeding me lines like “take a walk and be at one with nature” or “reach out and talk to someone” etc etc etc.

Im not here to get into that bull. Prevent Plagiarism. Identify unoriginal content with the world’s most effective plagiarism detection solution. Manage potential academic misconduct by highlighting similarities to the world’s largest collection of internet, academic, and student paper content.

For or against suicide?

Broadly speaking, pro-choicers argue that a person’s life belongs to no one but himself, and that his decision to commit suicide, especially if justified as a rational solution to real problems such as chronic and disabling pain, should be respected and assisted.

INDIRECT SUICIDE Suicide, perhaps the most obvious type of avoidable death at any age, is an intentional act that quickly results in death.

An argument on whether suicide in the final solution
Rated 3/5 based on 2 review
Fetal Attraction: Abortion and the Principle of Charity | Slate Star Codex